Site logo

My, You're Smart

FEATURE BY MAX NOBLE
24/07/2018

Some years back, in the coffee room at work, I was offering an opinion on the latest complexities appearing on front wing end plates. We were all sucking our teeth and generally offering the sort of semi-informed views and opinions that engineers love providing on areas of interest outside their core learning area.

To my surprise one staff member became somewhat indignant and strident of tone as they proceeded to tell the group that we were an uninformed, uneducated bunch of chipmunks who had not the slightest, not the very slightest, idea what we were talking about. We had all the understanding of the topic that the aforementioned forest dwelling rodent had of organic chemistry and the processes of nature that kept the nuts coming each autumn. Mildly taken aback, and having not yet finished my first coffee of the day, I crisply replied that as experienced engineers, that between us had worked on world class gas, oil, commercial, and defence projects, I felt we knew enough between us of basic aerodynamics, laminar flows, and boundary layers to have a half-sensible opinion on the subject.

No so! I was sternly informed. It took Great Intellect to work on the subtle delicacies of the Details of Physics. Great Intellect we lacked, and that we were then informed, this person's sibling did possess in abundance, as he was the technical director over-seeing the development of the very tricky item of science come art we were discussing, or more precisely I had been questioning. Ah...

So it was an interesting moment as the planet stopped turning and only the soft tick-ticking of the espresso machine filled the room.

I then expressed my delight at discovering their brother was in such an esteemed engineering position, before respectfully restating I was not a grade one chipmunk.

In return they gratefully accepted respect for their brother, before restating they knew a grade one chipmunk when they saw one, and I was he. Now in many matters of opinion a Gallic shrug of the shoulders and moving on, differences confirmed and accepted, is the adult thing to do. But most engineers are, at least to some extent, and with highly varying degrees of supporting justification, proud of their ability to think, reason, and problem solve. Hence my brow furrowed, which no doubt would have broken laminar flow over my skull had I been doing 350 kph along the Dottinger Hohe straight head first at the Nordschleife, but what would I know? This chipmunk was pushing back.

A brief, polite, word play ensued which ended with the robust assurance that of all the chipmunks in all the forests of the world it was axiomatic that I was the dumbest, and probably had mange and nut breath to boot. While I was formulating a witty, yet intelligent and mostly respectful comeback about why were there always so many nuts around said chipmunk the espresso machine elected to go into self-clean mode and emitted an alarming series of steam powered hisses and clanks that frightened the life out of the gathered chipmunks… I mean world class engineers, and before anyone could be beaten soundly with a signed edition of Bill Gate's "The Road Ahead" we thankfully dispersed.

Which brings me, dear reader, to the current topic that recalled that gladiatorial moment to my mind.

In the German GP press conference the driver's, other than reasonably wanting closer racing, and continuing fun, wanted to simplify the racing technology "for the fans".

Well I believe Ross Brawn is a fan of F1. As are most members of most teams. Do they sit around the garage all day moaning, "Gee, this is so complex, please Liberty Media save me!"...?

Many other fans have done simple things like design and develop aircraft, road cars, iPhones, new medical procedures, refined manufacturing techniques for a thousand useful items, and invent the Rubik Cube. Actually I'm not sure if Erno Rubik is a fan... but I know George Lucas and George Harrison have been to races... and Jenson Button at the time asked who "... the nice old man with the beard" was (after meeting George Harrison some years back). I feel comfortable saying that both these Georges can be considered fine intellects in their fields and would probably not have fainted if confronted with some basic high school physics in the name of saying what the big flat things at the front and rear of the racing wotsit were.

Indeed some arm waving along with napkins, bread rolls, and the water jug use around the concepts of the internal combustion engine would probably have sat reasonably well with them both too.

Could Ronaldo or Messi have explained all the detail of the planes they flew on to the Russian World Cup? Could they have explained the basic physics behind modern digital cameras, and the newly installed video assistant referee? Possibly not. It did not stop them playing football. If, when they were both gifted a couple of weeks free time due to being out the competition, one had sat down with them over a quiet mineral water, do you think they would have grasped a high school level explanation of these technologies? (For the sake of this piece I'm going with "Yes", ok).

So us the dear fan who needs to be rescued by Liberty Media and have F1 technology dumbed down because it makes our poor chipmunk minds hurt just to be on the same planet as such awesomeness, can we, dear reader, ever hope to grasp the immense accomplishment that is obeying the laws of physics while exceeding the speed of Hercule Poirot on the Orient Express?

Editor Balfe and I have enjoyed amusing feedback, blunt feedback, and highly informed and intelligent feedback over the years. Clearly much of our readership is far, far from the dumbest chipmunk in the forest. You are informed people. Many of you have worked, or still work, in complex areas of endeavour. Indeed many of you have worked in Motorsport in complex and demanding roles.

You are an informed, educated, thoughtful, highly capable readership. I will go out on a limb (well I guess I am a chipmunk and that has some advantages...) and say very few of our readers follow Wrestle-Mania and believe Elvis lives on the Dark Side of the Moon.

Laminar flow. Bernoulli's principle. Attached flow and stall angles. Pitch. Roll. Yaw. Any of you hyperventilating and reaching for your lucky rabbit paw to ease that racing heart? Didn't think so.

The laws of physics are nothing if not utterly uniform. Miss Physics holds the just and the unjust, the sainted and the haunted, the educated and the clueless to the same, the exact, precise, unwaveringly identical same, laws each and every nano-second we occupy this plane of existence.

And we as readers, and the wider F1 fan base, all somehow manage to execute our day jobs without requiring Liberty Media, or the FIA, to hold our hand while we, in sheer sweaty chipmunk terror, try to grapple with "smart stuff". How did anything outside Planet Paddock ever get built!?

In no order, Adrian Newey, Gordon Murray, Colin Chapman were, or still are, towering intellectual giants of the sport. They are folk who could envisage, create, plan, invent, and make real the most remarkable racing technology. I respect each of these engineering geniuses immensely. Could I, Maximus Chipmunk create what they did? No I could not. Could I understand what they had built and now it is in the stark light of day obeying the laws of physics we must all abide by, no matter our Alma mater or raw IQ score, gaze upon it and have some modest understanding of what's going on? Well, bold Chipmunk that I am, I will hold my lucky rabbit paw aloft (not so lucky for ol' thumper...) and shaking my fury fist at the sky yell "Indeed so! Physics I get Ye!"

So please, people of Planet Paddock, Aliens of Liberty Media, understand that out in the wide and varied trees of the forest, chipmunks, utterly without your help, engineer buildings and bridges, build computers, advance medical science, and generally get stuff done that requires a modest amount of intellect, and at least a "smiles in the Aldi car park" relationship with Miss Physics.

We might not have invented or engineered the remarkable solutions seen on the cars within F1, but we do have the skills to understand them once a genius has worked with Miss Physics to bring them into being.

So when we say, "Gee, those end-plates on that new front wing look over done and could be excessively sensitive to cross winds, or turbulence from the wake off the car in front." Please respect we might just know Miss Physics well enough to grasp some of the basics here.

Yes, your smarty pants brother is still super smart, but I reserve the right to scamper up the nearest chestnut tree and rain nuts on your head. The forest creatures may be revolting! Expect Liberty Media supplied F1 throwing nuts to be available at a dollar a handful at a nut store near you shortly. Those rodents can smell a Super Bowl Experience with dollars attached a mile off. And the world of international business does not obey the laws of Miss Physics. Yet us caring fans reserve the right to hold opinions based on our humble understanding of Physics, and to love our sport as we do because of the grace and elegance of the engineering solutions generated by the geniuses within the sport. Even if some sections of the forest would appear to be full of nuts.

Max Noble.

Learn more about Max and check out his previous features, here

RELATED ARTICLES

LATEST FEATURES

more features >

LATEST IMAGES

galleries >

  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images
  • Pitpass.com latest F1/Formula 1 images

POST A COMMENT

or Register for a Pitpass ID to have your say

Please note that all posts are reactively moderated and must adhere to the site's posting rules and etiquette.

Post your comment

READERS COMMENTS

 

1. Posted by Mig, 13/08/2018 16:46

"You always hit it on the head!!! Thank you for your insight!!!"

Rating: Positive (1)     Rate comment: Positive | NegativeReport this comment

2. Posted by imejl99, 01/08/2018 13:45

"@ClarkwasGod
6) Budget cap

Over the years we witnessed too much innovations banned
under "it will cost a fortune for others to develop" excuse. Like, "everything" in our power to reduce costs, so teams can survive.
And then, Force India."

Rating: Positive (1)     Rate comment: Positive | NegativeReport this comment

3. Posted by Max Noble, 01/08/2018 13:27

"@Spindoctor - very good point about the Schumacher Ferrari days... a “sound idea”... followed by the endless sweat of refinement and analysis until it was a “great engineered idea”. Agree that the testing limitation these days does amplify the benefit of a genius like Newey.. being nearly impossible to catch. Throw in design freezes as well and you are set for season’s long domination...

And big smile on the Sci-fi story. :-)

@Uffen - well a LOL moment for me... that adds up to a lot of misses in F1...! Indeed if Miss Physics had some solitude we might get back to some sane rules and close racing...

@ClarkwasGod - each season I ask myself why such a pragmatic, clear and easy to police approach is not take to the rules. It looks so elegant and practical from the outside... I guess all those nuts have gone to my chipmunk brain..."

Rating: Neutral (0)     Rate comment: Positive | NegativeReport this comment

4. Posted by ClarkwasGod, 31/07/2018 20:18

"Demolish the Rule "Wing" of the FIA (there are enough to warrant a whole building). Replace with "Rule Page" - A4 as follows:
1) Minimum weight - xxx kgs
2) Maximum Engine capacity - xxxx cc
3) Maximum Track - front - xxxx mm - rear - xxxx mm
4) Maximum wheelbase - xxxx mm
5) Maximum height - xxx cm

That's it.

Designers could exercise their brains in whatever direction they chose - we might actually be able to differentiate between the cars when in the naked state (without livery).



And then I woke up........."

Rating: Positive (1)     Rate comment: Positive | NegativeReport this comment

5. Posted by Uffen, 28/07/2018 1:11

"it is not so much the technology (and much of it I find tedious) it is where it has taken F1. F1 is now so micro-managed and precious that mega budgets rule the roost. Telemerty beamed around the world, drivers following detailed instructions on managing their car's power, consumption, diff settings, tire temperatures, etc.
Miss Physics rules it all but desperately needs Miss High Finance and Miss Marketing and Miss Lawyers and Miss Media and Miss White Elephant Venues to make it all happen. It has all become too, too much. "

Rating: Positive (2)     Rate comment: Positive | NegativeReport this comment

6. Posted by Spindoctor, 27/07/2018 8:23

"It's hard to be optimistic about anything, let alone F1 these days.
@imejl99 makes an excellent point that 'consumers' (that's us groundlings) are encouraged to care more about the capacity of door bins than the engineering of the chassis & drive-train when we make our 'purchasing decisions'.

Chapman et al were most influential in eras when the rules & laws of F1 were mainly subservient to those of Ms Physics. It wasn't Formula Libre, but smart people could innovate and evaluate their ideas with relative freedom.
A lot of 'proper' engineering (and indeed genius) is not about the eureka moment, but hard-work and attention to detail. Schumacher and Ferrari epitomised this: spending countless hours honing & refining the cars in testing. In the current era such testing is largely banned, and so when someone hits upon a successful formula[sic], like Newey's Red Bulls, or Mercedes' PUs the rest of the field has little opportunity to investigate or develop solutions. I suspect this is at the root of your antagonist's Chipmunk theory. When all the other smart-people in pit-lane are unable sufficiently to experiment and test ideas, whoever finds a good solution first, holds an advantage which might last for several seasons. This superficially and artificially elevates the quality of the 'invention' above the mere application of Ms Physic's discipline...

In the 1950's\60's a Sci-Fi writer I read as a youth posited a society in which (amongst other things) there were Jet Cars with speedos that showed speeds of 300mph - advanced technology seemed to abound.
A Time-Traveler from the 60's finds himself in this wonderland, only to discover that '300'mph is actually 30, and technology has hardly advanced in real terms. The masses don't realise this because they know that technology & science aren't for us Chipmunks, only for the demi-gods who 'invent' things.....
"

Rating: Positive (2)     Rate comment: Positive | NegativeReport this comment

7. Posted by cricketpo, 26/07/2018 17:14

"Well that is not quite what I said @maxnoble. A more democratic FIA FOR certain. Lots of rule a are what happens when some teams have a small army of engineers and lawyers all looking for the limit of any given envelope"

Rating: Positive (1)     Rate comment: Positive | NegativeReport this comment

8. Posted by Max Noble, 26/07/2018 0:11

"@Cricketpo - quite so! Reform of the FIA into a body that makes clear bounding rules, rather than prescribing them to the smallest detail, would be a fine solution!

@Insane Reindeer - good on you for trusting that you knew a good front wing revision when you saw one! "

Rating: Positive (1)     Rate comment: Positive | NegativeReport this comment

9. Posted by Insane Reindeer, 25/07/2018 14:20

"Thank you, thank you, thank you Max! I was beginning to wonder if I was the one who believed in crazy conspiracy theories. I saw an up close shot of the new for the German GP Renault front wing and exclaimed, out loud, in public, "That looks bloody amazing!" "

Rating: Positive (1)     Rate comment: Positive | NegativeReport this comment

10. Posted by cricketpo, 25/07/2018 13:13

"Well I am sorry that some one had the temerity to challenge your expertise in this area Max :) However the expressed views are the flipside of fan discussions. Your colleague however will soon find they are taking breaks on their own if they continue with the line of argument that just says "you know nothing". Said sibling probably works for Haas and is fed up of always working with last year's technology. (awaits howls of derision)
Of more concern is the so called dumbing down of F1. Whilst gone are the days of small teams like Williams of old taking on the big boys with smart engineering one doesn't want to see a CART or NASCAR solution where individual development is stymied by the rules. ( awaits more derision) F1 does have to be sustainable so if cheaper ways can be found to develop and innovate they should be grasped. My final gripe is that despite what some here think the FIA need to be in charge. It is not any teams place to disregard rules or deny change. The sports governing body makes the rules and the teams comply or don't race. The FIA should be owned and run by the fans however."

Rating: Positive (2)     Rate comment: Positive | NegativeReport this comment

11. Posted by Max Noble, 25/07/2018 10:40

"@imejl99 - ah... sadly yes. I believe you’re right that the composition of the fan base is changing... the question is can Liberty grow the total fan base by recruiting a few new, while frustrating many of the old...? Makes me go all mass-damper thinking about it... :-)

@Egalitarian - interesting evolutionary point... I guess we all have an inner chipmunk... some just embrace it more than others. And some go all feral-squirrel and that only leads to the dark side (if Editor Balfe made me pay for mixed-metaphor contortions I’d be broke...).

@R1Racing71 - LOL... as we all really know, Elvis now runs a second hand Surf Gear shop in Margaret River (WA) and sings softly to the Dolphins at Sunrise and the Whales (during migration) at Sunset. All good.

...and check out why the great Ian Dury didn’t write a piece for Andrew Lloyd-Webber :-). I believe Ian D. and Bernie are actually soul brothers. If only Ian had taken over the FIA after Mighty Max. Now THAT would have been entertainment! (Possibly an espresso too far today for me...). :-). "

Rating: Positive (1)     Rate comment: Positive | NegativeReport this comment

12. Posted by @R1Racing71, 25/07/2018 9:25

"Max, in the words of the great Ian Dury "There ain't half been some clever *******s""

Rating: Positive (1)     Rate comment: Positive | NegativeReport this comment

13. Posted by @R1Racing71, 25/07/2018 9:22

"The King is not dead! Say it ain't so Max say it ain't so."

Rating: Neutral (0)     Rate comment: Positive | NegativeReport this comment

14. Posted by Egalitarian, 25/07/2018 1:56

"Thanks Max. I too have worked with people that you are enduring. I do have one question. Using that person's logic i.e. "you don't work on it so you are chipmunk" does this mean that prior to having the opportunity to work on these devices, that the sibling was also a chipmunk? "

Rating: Positive (1)     Rate comment: Positive | NegativeReport this comment

15. Posted by imejl99, 24/07/2018 14:26

"Us caring fans will go down in history like blown diffuser or mass damper, with honorable mention as not exactly banned, but rather extinct. The frog is boiled. Millennials an Z-ers mostly care more for selfies, tweets, posts and general appearance than Physics. It became far more important if everyday car has 360 parking camera than what torque at what rpm. Although, grace and elegance of center console removable nuts pocket could turn a few heads :)"

Rating: Positive (4)     Rate comment: Positive | NegativeReport this comment

Share this page

X

Copyright © Pitpass 2002 - 2024. All rights reserved.

about us  |  advertise  |  contact  |  privacy & security  |  rss  |  terms